Forest Services
India’s BRICS Invitations Amid War: Context and Significance
In early 2024, India formally extended invitations to BRICS member countries—Brazil, Russia, China, South Africa, and itself—to participate in a series of high-level meetings scheduled throughout the year. These meetings, hosted across various Indian cities, occur against the backdrop of ongoing geopolitical tensions, including the Russia-Ukraine conflict and intensifying US-China rivalry. India’s proactive role in convening BRICS summits signals its intent to deepen multilateral engagement outside Western-dominated institutions, leveraging the grouping’s economic heft and diplomatic diversity for strategic balancing.
UPSC Relevance
- GS Paper 2: International Relations – Multilateralism, India’s Foreign Policy, BRICS dynamics
- GS Paper 3: Indian Economy – International trade, economic cooperation, development finance
- Essay: India’s role in emerging global governance structures
Constitutional and Legal Framework Governing India’s BRICS Engagement
India’s participation in BRICS is not directly governed by any constitutional provision. However, Article 253 of the Constitution of India empowers Parliament to legislate for implementing international treaties, which underpins India’s ability to engage in multilateral agreements. The Ministry of External Affairs Act, 1948 legally mandates the MEA to conduct diplomatic relations, including hosting international summits. Additionally, the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act, 2010 (FCRA) regulates foreign funding, ensuring transparency and compliance in financing international events like BRICS meetings.
- Article 253 enables Parliament to enact laws implementing international treaties.
- MEA Act, 1948 formalizes India’s diplomatic engagement framework.
- FCRA 2010 governs receipt and use of foreign contributions relevant to event funding.
Economic Dimensions of BRICS and India’s Role
BRICS countries collectively account for approximately 42% of the global population and 25% of global GDP as per World Bank 2023 data. India’s bilateral trade with BRICS nations reached around USD 150 billion in 2023, marking a 12% increase since 2020 (Ministry of Commerce, India). Hosting BRICS meetings requires an estimated INR 500 crore allocation by MEA to cover logistics, security, and protocol. The New Development Bank (NDB), established in 2014 by BRICS, has sanctioned over USD 30 billion in loans, primarily for infrastructure projects, with India as a significant beneficiary (NDB Annual Report 2023).
- BRICS contributes ~18% of global trade volume (UNCTAD, 2023).
- India’s trade share in BRICS increased by 12% from 2020 to 2023.
- INR 500 crore allocated for hosting BRICS summits in 2024 (MEA estimates).
- NDB loans exceed USD 30 billion since inception, supporting India’s infrastructure.
Key Institutions Facilitating India’s BRICS Engagement
The Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) leads India’s diplomatic coordination and protocol management for BRICS meetings, supported by its Protocol Division. The New Development Bank (NDB) finances infrastructure and sustainable development projects among BRICS countries. The BRICS Secretariat, rotating among member states, coordinates activities and summit preparations. The Ministry of Finance collaborates on economic and financial policy alignment related to BRICS cooperation, especially concerning trade facilitation and development finance.
- MEA: Diplomatic relations, summit hosting, protocol management.
- MEA Protocol Division: Event logistics and diplomatic protocol.
- NDB: Multilateral development bank funding BRICS infrastructure projects.
- BRICS Secretariat: Rotational coordination body for BRICS activities.
- Ministry of Finance: Economic policy coordination related to BRICS.
Comparative Analysis: BRICS vs Western Economic Groupings
| Aspect | BRICS | G7 | European Union (EU) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Membership | 5 emerging economies (Brazil, Russia, India, China, South Africa) | 7 advanced Western economies | 27 European countries with supranational governance |
| Economic Focus | Emerging market cooperation, infrastructure finance, multipolar governance | Advanced economies, global economic policy coordination | Integrated single market, common policies, monetary union (Eurozone) |
| Institutional Structure | Loose coordination, rotational secretariat, no supranational authority | Informal summitry, no binding decisions | Supranational institutions (Commission, Parliament, Court) |
| Development Finance | NDB provides alternative to Western-led World Bank | World Bank, IMF leadership | European Investment Bank, structural funds |
| Geopolitical Orientation | Multipolar, non-Western-centric | Western-centric, liberal democratic norms | Regional integration, normative governance |
Challenges in BRICS Cohesion and Strategic Agenda
BRICS members often diverge on strategic priorities, limiting the grouping’s institutional coherence. Unlike the EU’s supranational decision-making, BRICS operates on consensus without binding mechanisms, which hampers policy implementation. India, while seeking to balance China’s dominance, faces difficulties in forging unified positions, particularly on geopolitical issues such as the Russia-Ukraine war. This fragmentation contrasts with more integrated blocs and constrains BRICS’ potential as a cohesive alternative global governance platform.
- Lack of unified strategic agenda among BRICS members.
- Absence of supranational decision-making limits policy follow-through.
- India-China dynamics influence internal BRICS cohesion.
- Geopolitical conflicts (e.g., Russia-Ukraine) expose fault lines.
Significance and Way Forward
India’s hosting of BRICS meetings amid global conflict underscores its diplomatic strategy to reinforce multipolarity and diversify economic partnerships. The country aims to leverage BRICS to reduce overdependence on Western-led institutions and enhance South-South cooperation. Strengthening institutional mechanisms within BRICS, including a more permanent secretariat and clearer policy frameworks, would improve its effectiveness. India must also balance its engagement with China and Russia while promoting development finance and trade integration within the grouping.
- Use BRICS as a platform for diplomatic balancing amid geopolitical tensions.
- Enhance institutional coherence via permanent secretariat and policy roadmaps.
- Expand economic cooperation focusing on infrastructure and sustainable development.
- Maintain strategic autonomy by balancing relations within BRICS and with Western powers.
- Article 253 of the Indian Constitution directly mandates India’s participation in BRICS.
- The New Development Bank was established by BRICS to finance infrastructure projects.
- India’s trade with BRICS countries has increased by over 10% between 2020 and 2023.
Which of the above statements is/are correct?
- BRICS has a permanent supranational secretariat with binding decision-making powers.
- BRICS operates on consensus without supranational authority.
- BRICS members include both emerging and advanced economies.
Which of the above statements is/are correct?
What constitutional provision enables India to implement international treaties like those under BRICS?
Article 253 of the Constitution of India empowers Parliament to make laws for implementing international treaties and agreements, providing the constitutional basis for India’s engagement in multilateral groupings like BRICS.
What is the role of the New Development Bank (NDB) in BRICS cooperation?
The New Development Bank (NDB), established by BRICS in 2014, finances infrastructure and sustainable development projects among member countries, having sanctioned over USD 30 billion in loans by 2023.
How does India’s trade with BRICS countries compare to its overall global trade?
India’s trade with BRICS countries reached approximately USD 150 billion in 2023, constituting a significant portion of its global trade and reflecting a 12% increase since 2020, highlighting BRICS as a key economic partner.
What are the main challenges facing BRICS as a cohesive multilateral grouping?
BRICS faces challenges including lack of unified strategic agenda, absence of supranational decision-making, and divergent geopolitical interests among members, which limit its institutional coherence and policy implementation.
How does India’s hosting of BRICS meetings align with its foreign policy objectives?
India’s hosting of BRICS meetings aligns with its strategy to promote multipolar global governance, diversify economic partnerships beyond Western-led institutions, and balance relations with major powers like China and Russia.
About LearnPro Editorial Standards
LearnPro editorial content is researched and reviewed by subject matter experts with backgrounds in civil services preparation. Our articles draw from official government sources, NCERT textbooks, standard reference materials, and reputed publications including The Hindu, Indian Express, and PIB.
Content is regularly updated to reflect the latest syllabus changes, exam patterns, and current developments. For corrections or feedback, contact us at admin@learnpro.in.