Constitution, governance, social justice and institutional analysis
Examining the Success of the National Health Mission (NHM): Preventive vs Curative Healthcare Framework
The National Health Mission (NHM), combining the National Rural Health Mission (NRHM) and National Urban Health Mission (NUHM), is a cornerstone of India’s public health framework. Launched to meet preventive and curative healthcare goals, NHM underscores the tension between vertical program delivery (target-specific schemes like Maternal Health) and horizontal health system strengthening (general capacity-building). Evaluating its success reveals multidimensional impacts, including improved health indicators and governance restructuring, while exposing critical systemic limitations.
UPSC Relevance Snapshot
- GS Paper II: Governance, health sector policies, issues relating to development, and government schemes.
- GS Paper III: Inclusive growth and human resource development, role of technology in improving governance.
- Essay Angle: Health system interventions and their socio-economic impacts.
Conceptual Clarity: Preventive vs Curative Healthcare and Health Equity
The NHM operates within two intersecting paradigms: preventive healthcare (screening programs, immunization, wellness centers) and curative measures (dialysis programs, sickle cell management, TB treatment). While measurable success exists on both fronts, the alignment between systemic inputs and equitable outcomes remains under scrutiny.
- Preventive Success: Screenings for non-communicable diseases (109.55 crore in 2023-24), teleconsultation expansion (11.83 crore in 2023-24). Source: PIB.
- Curative Achievements: Sickle cell programs screened over 5 crore individuals, distributed 2.24 crore cards; National Dialysis Program provided services to 26.97 lakh patients across districts.
- Equity Challenges: Despite reductions in MMR and IMR, rural and marginalized populations remain disproportionately underserved. NFHS-5 shows urban-rural contrasts in institutional deliveries.
- WHO Benchmarks: India’s TB elimination programs align with the WHO’s 90-70-90 targets, although mortality reduction (21%) needs sustained efforts.
Evidence and Data: Measuring Outcomes of NHM
Quantitative metrics underline NHM’s robust contributions to public health, yet comparative assessments illustrate areas for improvement. NFHS, Economic Survey, and global health data provide reliable benchmarks.
| Indicator | Before NHM (2004-05) | After NHM (2021-22) | Global Average |
|---|---|---|---|
| Maternal Mortality Ratio (MMR) | 301 | 100 | 140 (WHO) |
| Infant Mortality Rate (IMR) per 1000 live births | 57 | 19 | 28 (UNICEF) |
| Total Fertility Rate (TFR) | 3.4 | 2.0 | 2.3 (World Bank) |
| Out-of-pocket health expenditure (%) | 69.4% | 39.4% | 18% (OECD) |
Limitations and Open Questions: Institutional and Systemic
While NHM has made remarkable strides, unresolved challenges persist. Structural inefficiencies and governance gaps constrain its full impact.
- Funding Challenges: Delays in fund disbursement at state levels restrict local interventions.
- Urban Health Coverage: NUHM’s integration remains inadequate to address rapid urbanization and migrant household healthcare needs.
- Overemphasis on Targets: Vertical programs, while achieving measurable goals, lack horizontal strengthening of primary health capacity.
- Behavioral Barriers: Socio-cultural practices impact maternal health and child immunization rates despite infrastructure availability.
Structured Assessment of the NHM
- Policy Design: Integration of NRHM and NUHM ensures focus on urban and rural health challenges. However, the emphasis on numerical targets risks ignoring unquantifiable systemic issues.
- Governance Capacity: Expanded human resources (5.23 lakh health workers in 2023-24) enhance institutional outreach, but persistent skill deficits constrain high-quality service delivery.
- Behavioral/Structural Factors: Out-of-pocket expenditure reduction (from 69.4% to 39.4%) indicates progress, yet inequities in health access remain stark for vulnerable groups.
Exam Integration: Practice Questions
Prelims MCQs:
- Consider the following statements about NHM:
1. It integrates preventive and curative healthcare goals.
2. NUHM covers rural areas only.
3. India met its Kala-azar elimination target under NHM.
Which of the above statements is/are correct?
(a) 1 only, (b) 2 and 3 only, (c) 1 and 3 only, (d) 1, 2, and 3 - Which of the following aligns with WHO’s 90-70-90 TB targets?
(a) 90% reduction in MMR, (b) 90% of TB cases notified, (c) 70% vaccination coverage, (d) 90% reduction in Kala-azar mortality
Mains Question (250 words):
Critically evaluate the achievements and challenges of the National Health Mission (NHM) in addressing India’s public health priorities. Highlight how preventive and curative healthcare models align within the framework of NHM.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the two primary components of the National Health Mission (NHM) in India?
The National Health Mission (NHM) is primarily composed of the National Rural Health Mission (NRHM) and the National Urban Health Mission (NUHM). This integration aims to address healthcare challenges in both rural and urban settings, emphasizing both preventive and curative healthcare goals.
How has the NHM impacted maternal and infant health indicators in India?
The NHM has significantly improved maternal and infant health indicators, with the Maternal Mortality Ratio (MMR) reducing from 301 to 100 per 100,000 live births and the Infant Mortality Rate (IMR) declining from 57 to 19 per 1,000 live births between 2004-05 and 2021-22. These figures illustrate the effectiveness of NHM’s health interventions in enhancing public health outcomes.
What are the main challenges faced by the National Health Mission (NHM) despite its successes?
Despite its successes, the NHM faces challenges such as structural inefficiencies, delays in funds disbursement, and inadequate urban health coverage. Additionally, there are persistent governance gaps and behavioral barriers that hinder equitable access to healthcare, particularly among rural and marginalized populations.
What does the term ‘health equity’ mean in the context of the National Health Mission (NHM)?
In the context of the NHM, ‘health equity’ refers to the fair distribution of health resources and outcomes, ensuring that all populations, especially vulnerable groups, have access to quality healthcare. Despite NHM’s achievements in reducing health disparities, significant gaps remain, particularly affecting rural and marginalized communities.
Get course, notes, test-series and answer-writing guidance for UPSC and State PSC preparation.