- A. The Question can be answered by using one of the Statements alone, but cannot be answered using the other Statement alone
- B. The Question can be answered by using either Statement alone
- C. The Question can be answered by using both the Statements together, but cannot be answered using either Statement alone
- D. The Question cannot be answered even by using both the Statements together
Answer: A
Explanation
Let the age of P be 10x + y and the age of Q be 10y + x, where x and y are digits from 1 to 9 (since ages are >10 and Q).**
10x + y > 10y + x => 9x > 9y => x > y.
Possible pairs (x,y) satisfying x>y and x,y are digits (y cannot be 0 as Q would be a single digit):
– If x=2, y=1 => P=21, Q=12. Difference = 9.
– If x=3, y=1 => P=31, Q=13. Difference = 18.
– If x=3, y=2 => P=32, Q=23. Difference = 9.
Since the difference is not unique, Statement I alone is insufficient.
**Statement II: The sum of their ages is 11/6 times their difference.**
P + Q = (11/6) * |P – Q|
(10x + y) + (10y + x) = (11/6) * |(10x + y) – (10y + x)|
11x + 11y = (11/6) * |9x – 9y|
11(x + y) = (11/6) * 9 * |x – y|
x + y = (9/6) * |x – y|
x + y = (3/2) * |x – y|
Since x and y are positive digits, x+y is positive. For the equation to hold, |x-y| must also be positive, implying x ≠ y. Also, for x+y to be a multiple of 3/2, x-y must be even. This means x and y must have the same parity. If x-y is positive, then x > y.
2(x + y) = 3(x – y)
2x + 2y = 3x – 3y
5y = x.
Since x and y are single digits (1-9) and y cannot be 0:
– If y=1, then x=5. This gives P = 51 and Q = 15. (P>Q is satisfied, 51>15).
– If y=2, then x=10 (not a single digit). No other solutions.
So, the only unique pair is (x=5, y=1), which means P=51 and Q=15.
The difference in their ages = P – Q = 51 – 15 = 36.
This uniquely determines the ages and their difference. Thus, Statement II alone is sufficient.
Therefore, the question can be answered by using Statement II alone, but not Statement I alone.